These are initial test hypotheses based on my experience as a prospective member. I’d validate them against Thrive’s current journey, existing experiments, and member economics.
01 / SHOW THE VALUE EARLIERLet the products help sell the membership.
Test a browsable selection of products, brands, and member prices before the membership gate. Give shoppers a way to see whether Thrive fits their actual grocery list.
Measure: Visitor-to-paid-member conversion and first-order completion; monitor acquisition cost and order margin.
02 / SIMPLIFY ONBOARDINGAsk less before the first “yes.”
Test a shorter path with optional or deferred preference questions. Compare it with the existing flow to understand where personalization helps and where it creates friction, especially on mobile.
Measure: Step-level abandonment, paid membership conversion, and time to first order.
03 / TEST THE OFFERMake the reason to join more compelling.
Test the limited-time offer’s framing and placement against a clear explanation of ongoing membership value. Then compare incentive types, such as a first-order discount or gift, with transparent terms and genuine deadlines.
Measure: Cost per activated member, incentive-adjusted margin, and early cancellation.
04 / CONNECT AD TO EXPERIENCEContinue the promise after the click.
Test landing pages aligned with the reason someone clicked: saving on everyday staples, finding products for dietary needs, or making family shopping easier. Carry the same promise through to onboarding.
Measure: Paid member conversion and acquisition cost by audience, creative, and landing page.
05 / RE-ENGAGE THE ALMOST-MEMBERAnswer the hesitation that stopped them.
Test remarketing for people who started but did not finish joining. Compare messages about product selection, membership value, and how it works, with a direct path back to the next step.
Measure: Incremental paid memberships against a holdout, acquisition cost, and first orders.
06 / CONNECT SIGNUP TO ACTIVATIONMake the first order part of acquisition.
Test a guided first basket or relevant product recommendations after signup. Evaluate acquisition cohorts through the first and repeat order so a stronger signup rate translates into lasting member value.
Measure: First-order rate, time to purchase, repeat ordering, and contribution by cohort.
WHERE I’D STARTMap abandonment by step, device, and acquisition source. Prioritize the shopping preview and shorter onboarding tests based on reach, effort, and expected impact, then test the offer separately to isolate what changes behavior.
The goal: More members who place an order and keep shopping, with acquisition cost and contribution margin evaluated together.